The TRUTH About Selling A.I. Art...

The video discusses the burgeoning market for AI-generated art and the controversies surrounding it, including legal and ethical concerns. Despite recent lawsuits and debates over copyright, the presenter argues that selling AI art is profitable, citing several successful online shops. The video also touches on the current legal stance where AI-generated works do not receive the same copyright protection as human-created works. It further explores ethical considerations, with a focus on the argument that AI lacks the human element of inspiration and creativity, potentially threatening artistic individuality. The presenter invites viewers to share their thoughts on the use of AI in art and its commercial viability.

Takeaways

• 📈 AI-generated artwork has seen a significant increase in sales across the internet, with some claiming substantial monthly earnings.
• 🤔 There is ongoing controversy regarding the legality and ethics of selling AI art, with concerns about copyright infringement and the impact on human artists.
• 🎨 Successful examples of AI art sales are presented, with some businesses making thousands of sales and substantial monthly profits.
• 💡 The profitability of AI art is emphasized, noting a high profit margin for digital products, with some sellers earning tens of thousands of dollars within their first year.
• ⚖️ Legal concerns are addressed, highlighting that current copyright law does not extend to AI-generated works, treating them more like public domain.
• 🚫 The risk of directly copying AI art for sale is discussed, as it could lead to legal repercussions and financial damages.
• 📝 Copyright basics are explained, including the difference between automatic registration and pre-registration, and the potential for statutory damages in case of infringement.
• 📉 A recent lawsuit against AI companies for copyright infringement is mentioned, with the judge finding no substantial similarity between AI-generated images and the original works.
• 🛡️ The importance of copyright registration is highlighted, especially for works that are not officially registered but rely on automatic protection upon creation.
• 🧐 Ethical considerations are presented, including arguments that AI lacks the human element of inspiration and creativity, and that it may promote theft and forgery.
• 🤝 An alternative view suggests that AI can be a collaborative tool for artists to explore new creative possibilities, rather than a threat to individuality and authenticity in art.

Q & A

What has been the trend in AI generated artwork sales over the last few years?

Over the last few years, there has been an absolute explosion in the creation and sale of AI generated artwork across the internet.

What is the controversy surrounding AI generated artwork?

The controversy includes legal concerns, ethical issues, and skepticism about the viability of selling AI art. Some believe it should be illegal due to copyright infringement, others argue it's unethical as it steals from human artists, and some doubt its marketability.

How much profit can one make by selling AI generated images?

It is claimed that one can make between $10,000 to $40,000 a month by selling AI generated images.

What is the current legal stance on AI generated artwork and copyright?

As of the recent ruling by a US judge, AI generated media does not receive the same copyright protection as human-created works. This is because courts have declined to recognize copyright in works created without any human involvement.

How does the profit margin for digital AI art compare to other products?

Digital AI art products have a profit margin of around 91% after all fees, which is quite substantial.

What is the current status of the class action lawsuit against AI companies?

The lawsuit faced several issues, including a lack of substantial similarity between the artists' images and those created by AI, and the fact that only one of the three defendants had registered their works with the US Copyright Office. The judge indicated the case might be dismissed but allowed individual plaintiffs to refile.

What are the ethical concerns raised by artists regarding AI generated art?

Artists are concerned that AI art steals from their work, promotes theft to the masses, and threatens individuality in art by being unable to contribute authentic, individual expression.

How can artists collaborate with AI without ethical concerns?

Artists can use AI as a tool to explore new creative possibilities, ensuring they are responsible for the direction and not replicating another artist's work directly.

null

null

What is the current market for AI generated art on platforms like Etsy?

AI generated art is not only allowed to be sold on platforms like Etsy, but it also sells quite well, with some shops reaching significant sales and monthly revenue.

What are the risks for someone trying to steal and resell AI generated designs?

The risks include legal repercussions for copyright infringement, the need to be certain that the design was made entirely with AI, and the potential violation of platform policies such as duplicate shop or unauthorized reproductions.

How does the speaker suggest viewers form their own opinion on the topic?

The speaker invites viewers to share their thoughts in the comments section regarding the use and profitability of AI art.

Outlines

00:00

🎨 AI Artwork Controversy and Profitability

The video discusses the recent surge in AI-generated artwork being sold online and addresses the controversy surrounding it. Despite the debate, the speaker shares examples of successful AI art sales, with some shops making significant profits. The video aims to explore the legal and ethical concerns while also testing the audience's ability to identify AI-made art.

05:02

🤖 Legal Concerns and Copyright Protection

The video delves into the legal aspects of AI-generated art, noting that current copyright law does not extend to AI-created works. It explains the difference between automatic copyright registration and proactive pre-registration, and the potential damages one can claim if their copyright is infringed. The video also discusses a class action lawsuit against AI companies, highlighting the complexities and challenges in proving copyright infringement in the context of AI.

10:02

🧑‍🎨 Ethical Considerations and the Role of AI in Art

The video presents ethical arguments against AI-generated art, emphasizing the distinction between human inspiration and AI's reliance on existing data. It discusses the concerns of forgery and plagiarism, and the potential threat AI poses to individuality in art. The speaker suggests that artists can collaborate with AI to explore new creative possibilities and invites the audience to share their thoughts on the use of AI art for profit.

Keywords

💡AI generated artwork

AI generated artwork refers to pieces of art that are created using artificial intelligence algorithms. These algorithms can generate images, designs, and patterns that mimic or even surpass the creativity of human artists. In the video, it is discussed how such artwork has been sold online, with some artists making significant profits from it. However, it also raises legal and ethical concerns regarding copyright and the originality of AI-created pieces.

💡Class action lawsuit

A class action lawsuit is a type of legal action in which a large group of individuals with similar claims against another party come together to sue as a group. In the context of the video, a class action lawsuit has been filed against major AI companies by artists who claim that their copyrighted images were used to train AI models without their consent, which they argue is a violation of their rights.

💡Copyright

Copyright is a legal right that grants the creator of an original work exclusive rights to its use and distribution, usually for a limited time. The video discusses the complexities of copyright law in relation to AI-generated art, noting that current U.S. copyright law does not extend protection to works created without human involvement, which includes most AI-generated media.

💡Profitability

Profitability refers to the ability to generate income or profits from a particular venture or business. The video explores the profitability of selling AI art, providing examples of online shops that have made significant sales and monthly profits from offering AI-generated digital downloads and art prints.

💡Ethical standpoint

An ethical standpoint is a perspective based on moral principles that guide beliefs and actions. The video addresses the ethical concerns surrounding AI art, such as whether it is right to profit from art that may be derived from the works of human artists without their consent or compensation.

💡Generative AI algorithms

Generative AI algorithms are a subset of artificial intelligence that can create new content, such as images or music, based on existing data. The video mentions these algorithms in the context of creating AI-generated artwork, which can be sold as digital downloads or prints.

💡Public domain

Public domain refers to creative works that are not protected by intellectual property laws such as copyright, and are therefore free to be used by anyone for any purpose. The video suggests that, under current law, AI-generated art is treated more like public domain content than original pieces of art due to the lack of human involvement in its creation.

💡Actual damages

Actual damages in legal terms refer to the measurable economic harm that a party has suffered as a result of another party's actions. The video explains that if a work is infringed upon, the copyright holder can sue for actual damages, which requires proving financial loss caused by the infringement.

💡Statutory damages

Statutory damages are predetermined compensation amounts established by law for certain types of copyright infringement. The video notes that if a copyright is pre-registered and then infringed, the copyright holder can sue for statutory damages, which can range from $750 to $150,000 per infringement, without needing to prove actual financial loss.

💡Human involvement

Human involvement implies the active participation or creative input of a person in a process. In the context of the video, it is mentioned that for a work to be eligible for copyright protection, it must be created with some degree of human involvement, which is currently lacking in most AI-generated works.

💡Individuality in art

Individuality in art refers to the unique personal expression and style that an artist brings to their work. The video discusses the ethical argument that AI-generated art may threaten individuality by replicating styles and potentially promoting theft, as opposed to contributing authentic, individualized creative insights.

Highlights

AI-generated artwork has seen a significant increase in production and sales across the internet.

Controversy exists around the legality and ethics of selling AI art, with opinions varying widely.

Some believe AI art infringes on the rights of human artists by 'stealing' their work.

There are doubts about the viability of selling AI art as a profitable venture.

A shop selling digital AI clip art started 9 months ago and has made around £55,000 per month.

Another shop, 'Get Your Clip Art,' openly states that all their art is generated using AI.

Despite only being on Etsy for 6 months, one shop has made $6,000 by selling AI-generated art.

AI art can be profitable, with digital products offering around a 91% profit margin.

Under current U.S. copyright law, AI-generated media does not receive the same copyright protection as human-created works.

AI-generated art is treated more like public domain content than original pieces of art.

Most works are not officially registered for copyright, relying on automatic registration upon creation.

Pre-registering a copyright can provide stronger protection against infringement.

The risk of selling copied AI art is high due to potential legal repercussions.

The first class action lawsuit against AI companies for copyright infringement faced several legal challenges.

The judge in the lawsuit found no substantial similarity between the AI-generated images and the original artist's work.

Only one of the three defendants in the lawsuit had registered their works with the U.S. Copyright Office.

Currently, there are no laws against selling AI artwork, and it sells well on platforms like Etsy.

Ethical concerns revolve around AI's potential to steal and sell human art, and the lack of unique individuality in AI creations.

AI is seen by some as a threat to authentic individual art and human creativity.

The debate continues on whether AI art should be allowed for profit and how it impacts the art world.