Leonardo AI vs Midjourney for Ai Art

Wade McMaster - Creator Impact
11 Sept 202309:51

TLDRIn this video, the host compares two leading AI art platforms, Leonardo AI and Midjourney, to help viewers make an informed decision. Leonardo AI offers a free trial and a slightly more expensive subscription, while Midjourney lacks a free trial but has a lower entry-level price. The interface of Leonardo AI is more straightforward, making it beginner-friendly, but Midjourney's simplicity in text input for image generation is favored by intermediate users. Both platforms have their strengths; Leonardo AI provides advanced image editing tools and the ability to train models, while Midjourney offers more control over image parameters. In terms of image quality, Leonardo AI can produce higher resolution images, but Midjourney is often easier to achieve good results with less effort. The host leans towards Midjourney for its ease of use and quick image generation once familiar with the platform, but acknowledges that the choice depends on individual needs and preferences.

Takeaways

  • 🆓 **Free Trial**: Leonardo AI offers a free trial, unlike Midjourney, making it a better choice for those who want to start without any financial commitment.
  • 💵 **Pricing**: Both platforms have similar pricing structures, with Leonardo AI's lowest tier at $12/month compared to Midjourney's $10/month.
  • 🛠️ **Ease of Use**: Leonardo AI has a simpler interface, making it more user-friendly for beginners compared to Midjourney, which operates on Discord and can be confusing for new users.
  • 📈 **Advanced Features**: Leonardo AI provides more advanced image editing tools, like Canvas, and features like prompt generation and prompt magic for paid users.
  • 🔍 **Model Control**: Midjourney allows for easier control over image generation through text inputs, whereas Leonardo AI requires understanding of models and settings for specific styles.
  • 📱 **User Interface**: Once users are intermediate, Midjourney becomes simpler with direct text input, while Leonardo AI can be more complex to achieve desired results.
  • 🖼️ **Image Quality**: Leonardo AI can produce higher resolution images by default and offers more flexibility in resolution settings.
  • 🤖 **Model Training**: Leonardo AI allows users to train their own models, a feature not yet available in Midjourney.
  • 🧑 **Human Faces**: Both platforms are good at generating human faces, but Midjourney might be slightly easier to achieve good results.
  • 🌿 **Scene Creation**: Leonardo AI tends to create images that closely match the description, while Midjourney's results may require additional keywords for photorealism.
  • 🎨 **Anime & Abstract Art**: Midjourney produced more vibrant colors and better framed images in anime and abstract styles compared to Leonardo AI.

Q & A

  • Which platform offers a free trial for AI art and image generation?

    -Leonardo AI offers a free trial, while Midjourney does not currently have one.

  • What is the main difference in pricing between Leonardo AI and Midjourney's lowest tier?

    -Leonardo AI's lowest tier is priced at $12 a month, which is slightly more expensive than Midjourney's $10 a month.

  • Which platform is easier for beginners to use due to its interface?

    -Leonardo AI has a simpler and more straightforward interface, making it easier for beginners compared to Midjourney, which operates on Discord.

  • What feature does Leonardo AI have that can be both a strength and a weakness?

    -Leonardo AI has different models that allow users to explore certain styles more effectively, but this can also make the process more complicated.

  • In terms of image editing capabilities, which platform is more advanced?

    -Leonardo AI has a more advanced image editing capability with features like prompt generation, prompt magic, Alchemy for paid users, and a canvas tool.

  • What is the default resolution for images generated by Leonardo AI and Midjourney?

    -Leonardo AI can produce higher resolution images by default compared to Midjourney, which typically generates images around 1024 by 1024.

  • Which platform is better for producing high-quality human faces?

    -While both platforms are good at producing human faces, Midjourney is slightly easier to use and tends to yield better results most of the time.

  • What is the advantage of using an external AI upscaler like Topaz Gigapixel?

    -External AI upscalers can improve the resolution of images generated by AI art platforms, taking them to a higher level since neither platform currently produces ultra high resolution images.

  • Which platform allows users to train their own models?

    -Midjourney allows users to train their own models, a feature that is not yet available in Leonardo AI.

  • What is the author's personal preference between Leonardo AI and Midjourney?

    -The author personally prefers Midjourney due to its simplicity once learned and the ability to quickly produce images by typing in a prompt on a phone.

  • What is the conclusion regarding which platform is better for AI art and image generation?

    -There is no clear winner as it depends on the user's needs. Leonardo AI is better for those on a strict budget or who want a complete platform with editing capabilities, while Midjourney is simpler to use and quicker for image generation once the user is past the beginner stage.

Outlines

00:00

🎨 Comparing Leonardo AI and Mid-Journey for AI Art Generation

The video script begins by addressing the viewer's potential interest in choosing between Leonardo AI and Mid-Journey, two leading platforms for AI art and image generation. It highlights that Leonardo AI offers a free trial, unlike Mid-Journey, making it initially more appealing for those unwilling to invest money. The pricing of both platforms is noted to be quite similar, with Leonardo AI's lowest tier slightly more expensive. The ease of use is compared, with Leonardo AI's straightforward interface being favored over Mid-Journey's Discord-based operation, which can be daunting for beginners. However, once users become intermediates, Mid-Journey's text-based control is noted to be more accessible. The features of both platforms are discussed, with Leonardo AI praised for its advanced image editing tools and model variety, while Mid-Journey is recognized for its extensive control parameters and model training capabilities. The discussion leans slightly towards Leonardo AI for its editing capabilities and use of personal photos, but acknowledges that both platforms are evenly matched in terms of features.

05:01

📊 Image Resolution and Quality Comparison

The script moves on to compare the image generation capabilities of Leonardo AI and Mid-Journey, starting with resolution. Leonardo AI is noted to produce higher resolution images by default, offering more flexibility, whereas Mid-Journey's images are limited to a 1024 by 1024 resolution. The use of external AI upscalers is suggested for achieving ultra-high resolution images, as neither platform currently offers this. The quality of images produced by both platforms is then evaluated through various tests, including human faces, a T-Rex terrorizing a playground, a rainforest with mystical energy, and anime-style characters. While both platforms perform well, it is observed that Leonardo AI sometimes requires more effort to avoid errors and achieve the desired outcome. Mid-Journey is found to be simpler to use once the initial learning curve is overcome, and it is preferred for its ease of generating images through basic text prompts. The conclusion is that neither platform is definitively better, as it depends on the user's specific needs and preferences. The speaker personally favors Mid-Journey for its simplicity and quick image generation, complemented by the use of an external upscaler for higher resolution needs.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Leonardo AI

Leonardo AI is an AI art and image generation platform that is compared with Midjourney in the video. It offers a free trial and has a user-friendly interface, which is straightforward to navigate. It also provides advanced features like different models, prompt generation, and an advanced image editing tool called Canvas. In the video, Leonardo AI is highlighted for its ability to produce higher resolution images and its flexibility in upscaling.

💡Midjourney

Midjourney is another AI art and image generation platform that is compared with Leonardo AI. It operates on Discord, which might be a barrier for beginners. However, once users get accustomed to it, it is considered simpler to use, especially for intermediate users. The platform is known for its ease of generating images based on text inputs and for having more control parameters and tools for image generation.

💡Free Trial

A free trial is an opportunity for users to try out a service without any financial commitment. In the context of the video, Leonardo AI offers a free trial, which gives it an advantage over Midjourney for users who want to test the platform before deciding to pay for it.

💡Pricing

Pricing refers to the cost of using a service or product. The video discusses the pricing of both Leonardo AI and Midjourney, noting that they are quite similar, with Leonardo AI's lowest tier being slightly more expensive at $12 per month compared to Midjourney's $10 per month.

💡Interface

The interface is the point of interaction between the user and the software. The video mentions that Leonardo AI has a simple and straightforward interface, which is beneficial for ease of use, while Midjourney's use of Discord might be more challenging for beginners.

💡Resolution

Resolution in the context of image generation refers to the level of detail an image can display, which is measured by the number of pixels. The video compares the resolution capabilities of Leonardo AI and Midjourney, noting that Leonardo AI can produce higher resolution images by default.

💡Alchemy

Alchemy is a feature within Leonardo AI that allows for more advanced image generation capabilities. It is mentioned in the video as a strength of Leonardo AI, suggesting that it can help users explore and create certain styles more effectively.

💡Canvas

Canvas is an advanced image editing tool available in Leonardo AI. The video highlights it as a significant advantage over Midjourney's image editing features, as it provides users with more control over editing small details of an image.

💡Text-to-Image

Text-to-image is a feature in AI art platforms where users input text prompts to generate images. The video discusses how Midjourney allows for simpler text-to-image generation, making it more accessible for users once they are past the initial learning curve.

💡Error Avoidance

Error avoidance refers to the capability of a platform to minimize mistakes or errors in the generated images. The video suggests that Leonardo AI might have a higher likelihood of producing errors compared to Midjourney, which is an important consideration for users seeking high-quality outputs.

💡Upscaling

Upscaling is the process of increasing the resolution of an image without losing quality. The video mentions the use of external AI upscalers like Topaz Gigapixel for taking images to a higher resolution level, as neither platform currently produces ultra-high resolution images on their own.

Highlights

Leonardo AI offers a free trial, unlike Midjourney, making it the better choice for those starting without spending money.

Both platforms are considered the best in the market for AI art and image generation.

Leonardo AI's lowest tier is priced at $12/month, compared to Midjourney's $10/month.

Midjourney operates on Discord, which may be a barrier for beginners.

Leonardo AI has a simple and straightforward interface, making it easier to use for beginners.

Leonardo AI provides more advanced image editing capabilities, including a tool called Canvas.

Midjourney allows for more control over the image generation process with various codes and parameters.

Leonardo AI can produce higher resolution images by default compared to Midjourney.

Midjourney is easier to use once you become more intermediate with the platform.

Leonardo AI offers different models and features like prompt generation and prompt magic for paid users.

Midjourney's image generation tends to produce more attractive layouts but may require additional keywords for photorealism.

Leonardo AI can be more challenging to avoid errors when creating images.

Midjourney's simplicity in image generation makes it more user-friendly once the initial learning curve is overcome.

Leonardo AI is more complete with the ability to train models and perform all edits within one platform.

The choice between Leonardo AI and Midjourney depends on the user's needs, budget, and preference for image quality and resolution.

The presenter personally prefers Midjourney due to its simplicity and ability to quickly generate images with fewer errors.

Both platforms have their strengths, and the best choice is subjective based on individual requirements and preferences.