Diablo 4 Is Pay 2 Win

The video script discusses the pay-to-win controversy surrounding 'Diablo 4'. The speaker presents three pieces of evidence to support their claim that the game offers advantages to those who spend real money, particularly through the battle pass system. They explain how 'ashes' in the battle pass, which provide XP boosts and other bonuses, are tied to character and battle pass levels, creating a situation where players must either progress optimally or stop to perform tasks to unlock these benefits. The speaker argues that while the advantage is marginal, it's an advantage nonetheless, and if not addressed, could lead to a more serious pay-to-win scenario in the future. They also note the oddity of people defending such a system, questioning their motives.

Takeaways

• 💥 The title suggests that 'Diablo 4' has a 'Pay to Win' model, implying that players can gain advantages by spending real money.
• 📖 The transcript argues that the game's battle pass system provides an advantage through the use of 'ashes', which can be seen as a form of 'Pay to Win'.
• 🔒 Ashes are locked behind character level and battle pass level, requiring players to reach certain levels to unlock them.
• 🔄 Players can swipe to get ashes instantly if they meet the level requirements, which can disrupt the natural leveling process.
• 🛠️ The game's leveling system has been updated to be faster, which can lead to players outleveling the battle pass and potentially missing out on ashes.
• 🎓 If players choose not to swipe for ashes, they must perform additional tasks, which can put them behind those who do swipe.
• 🤔 The transcript speculates that the issue might be unintentional due to poor math on Blizzard's part, rather than a deliberate 'Pay to Win' strategy.
• 🔄 The speaker doubts that Blizzard intentionally designed the game to be 'Pay to Win', but acknowledges the possibility of psychological tactics to encourage swiping.
• 🚫 The transcript suggests that making ashes unlock based only on character level could be a simple solution to the problem.
• 📈 The concern is raised that if the battle pass continues to buff XP, it could lead to a more significant 'Pay to Win' situation in the future.
• 🤷‍♂️ The speaker expresses confusion over why some people would defend the 'Pay to Win' model, questioning their motivations.

Q & A

What is the main concern expressed in the title about Diablo 4?

The main concern expressed in the title is that Diablo 4 is 'Pay 2 Win', suggesting that the game offers advantages to players who make real money purchases.

What does the speaker define as 'Pay to Win' in the context of Diablo 4?

The speaker defines 'Pay to Win' as a system where players gain an advantage by making real money purchases, and they are not interested in arguing semantics or different definitions.

What is the 'battle pass' and how is it related to 'Pay to Win' in Diablo 4?

The 'battle pass' is a feature in Diablo 4 where players can get 'ashes' that provide bonuses such as XP boosts. The speaker argues that this system is a form of 'Pay to Win' because these ashes are locked behind character and battle pass levels, creating an advantage for those who can progress faster.

How are 'ashes' in the battle pass used to provide bonuses in Diablo 4?

Ashes in the battle pass are used to provide bonuses such as increased XP gain for the character and bonus glyph XP from Nightmare dungeons.

Why does the speaker believe that the current system for unlocking 'ashes' is problematic?

The speaker believes the system is problematic because 'ashes' are locked behind both character level and battle pass level, which can force players to stop leveling optimally to perform chores and unlock these ashes, potentially putting them behind in progression.

What is the potential issue with the leveling system in Diablo 4 as described by the speaker?

The potential issue is that the leveling system has been updated to be faster, which can lead to players outleveling the battle pass. This could inadvertently create a 'Pay to Win' scenario where players who can afford to progress faster gain an advantage.

What is the speaker's opinion on Blizzard's handling of the leveling and battle pass system?

The speaker suggests that Blizzard may not have intentionally designed the system to be 'Pay to Win', but rather it could be a result of poor mathematical planning or an oversight.

What solution does the speaker propose to address the issue with the 'ashes' in the battle pass?

The speaker proposes that the issue could be easily solved if 'ashes' unlocked based only on character level, which would remove the forced chore and leveling discrepancy.

Why does the speaker believe that the current advantage provided by the battle pass is marginal but still concerning?

The speaker believes it's marginal because the advantage provided is small, but it's concerning because if left unchecked and XP continues to be buffed in the battle pass, it could lead to a more significant 'Pay to Win' situation in the future.

What is the speaker's view on the people defending the current system in Diablo 4?

The speaker is puzzled by those defending the system, questioning whether they are fans of 'Pay to Win' mechanics or are simply supporting the game's developer without critical thought.

Outlines

00:00

🕹️ Pay-to-Win Concerns in Gaming

The speaker expresses frustration with perceived pay-to-win mechanics in a game, specifically criticizing the battle pass system. They argue that players who spend real money gain an advantage through 'ashes,' which provide bonuses like increased XP and glyph XP from Nightmare dungeons. These ashes are tied to both character and battle pass levels, creating a scenario where players must either progress through levels or perform in-game chores to unlock them, potentially disrupting the leveling process. The speaker suggests that this system could unintentionally lead to a pay-to-progress model and expresses concern about the potential for future mechanics to become pay-to-win if not properly balanced.

Keywords

Pay to Win

Pay to Win refers to a model in video games where players can gain advantages over others by making real money purchases. In the context of the video, the speaker argues that 'Diablo 4' has elements of this model because players can buy 'ashes' in the battle pass that provide bonuses such as XP boosts, which can give them an edge over non-paying players.

Battle Pass

A Battle Pass is a feature in many online games that offers players a series of rewards they can earn by playing the game. In the video, the speaker explains that in 'Diablo 4', the Battle Pass contains 'ashes' which can be used to unlock bonuses, suggesting that progression through the Battle Pass can provide players with advantages.

Ashes

In the script, 'ashes' are a type of in-game currency in 'Diablo 4' that are earned through the Battle Pass and can be used to unlock various bonuses. The speaker points out that these ashes are locked behind character and Battle Pass levels, implying that players who spend money to level up faster can gain these bonuses more quickly.

XP Boost

An XP Boost is a feature in games that increases the rate at which a player gains experience points. The video discusses how 'ashes' obtained through the Battle Pass in 'Diablo 4' can provide an XP boost, which can be seen as an advantage for players who are willing to pay to progress faster.

Nightmare Dungeons

Nightmare Dungeons are a type of challenging game mode in 'Diablo 4' that offer players the opportunity to earn bonus glyph XP. The script mentions that 'ashes' from the Battle Pass can provide bonus glyph XP from Nightmare Dungeons, suggesting that paying for the Battle Pass can offer additional advantages in these game modes.

Character Level

Character Level is a measure of a player's progress in a game, typically indicating their strength and capabilities. In the video, the speaker explains that 'ashes' are locked behind certain character levels, which means that players must reach a certain point in the game before they can unlock the advantages provided by the Battle Pass.

Season Journey

The Season Journey is a feature in 'Diablo 4' that allows players to complete tasks and challenges to progress through the game. The speaker criticizes the game for requiring players to stop their progress and complete 'chores' in the Season Journey to unlock 'ashes', which they argue is a form of pay-to-progress.

Outlevel

To 'outlevel' in the context of the video means to progress beyond the level required to unlock certain features or rewards. The speaker notes that in previous seasons of 'Diablo 4', players could not outlevel the Battle Pass, but now that leveling has been made faster, players can outlevel the Battle Pass and miss out on certain rewards unless they pay.

Psychologists

The speaker mentions psychologists in the context of companies hiring them to encourage players to make in-game purchases. This suggests that the design of the Battle Pass and the unlocking of 'ashes' might be influenced by psychological tactics to prompt players to spend more money.

White Knight

A 'White Knight' is a term used to describe someone who defends or supports a person, group, or idea, often without fully understanding the implications. In the script, the speaker questions why people would defend the pay-to-win aspects of 'Diablo 4', suggesting that they might be acting as 'White Knights' for the game company.

Highlights

Diablo 4 is accused of being pay-to-win, with real money purchases giving players an advantage.

The term 'pay-to-win' is defined as gaining an advantage through real money purchases.

The speaker dismisses arguments about semantics and focuses on the core issue of paying for advantages.

The battle pass in Diablo 4 is a point of contention, as it offers 'ashes' for bonuses.

Ashes in the battle pass can be used for bonuses like XP boosts and glyph XP from Nightmare dungeons.

Ashes are locked behind character level and battle pass level, requiring both to be unlocked.

If a player's battle pass level is lower than their character level, they can swipe to get ashes instantly.

Not swiping for ashes requires players to stop and perform chores to level up their battle pass.

Performing chores to level up can put players behind those who swipe for ashes and continue leveling.

Previous seasons did not have the issue of outleveling the battle pass, but the leveling system has been updated.

The speaker suggests that the issue may not have been intentional due to poor math by the developers.

A simple solution is proposed to make ashes unlock based only on character level.

The advantage gained from swiping for ashes is described as marginal but still significant.

There is concern that if XP continues to be buffed in the battle pass, it could lead to a more serious pay-to-win situation.

Blizzard's tendency to make games easier raises concerns about future mechanics inadvertently becoming pay-to-win.

The speaker finds it strange that some people are defending the pay-to-win aspects of Diablo 4.

Defenders of the pay-to-win mechanics are either fans of the concept or seen as 'white knights' for the company.