Gender bias in recruitment
Summary
TLDRThe conversation in the script highlights a workplace discussion between two individuals about hiring decisions. Diane, the boss, suggests hiring Johanna, but another manager raises concerns about hiring more women, mentioning that two employees are on maternity leave and expressing worry about potential future pregnancies. Despite acknowledging Karen's qualifications, the speaker favors hiring a male candidate, Michael, who lacks industry experience but is seen as a safer choice. The conversation reflects tension between workplace diversity policies and practical challenges in achieving business targets.
Takeaways
- 👩💼 Diane is the boss and believes Johanna should be considered.
- 🤔 There is some doubt about Johanna's suitability from the speaker.
- 👩⚖️ The speaker acknowledges Karen fits the job specification and the company wants to hire more women.
- 🍼 The speaker is concerned about hiring another woman who might go on maternity leave, citing that two of their best employees are currently on maternity leave.
- 🤐 Johanna did not mention anything about wanting to have children, but the speaker is concerned it might happen in the future.
- 🤷♂️ The speaker is trying to balance the need for diversity with practical concerns about hitting targets with people potentially leaving.
- 👨💼 The speaker expresses a preference for a male candidate, Michael, who ticked all the boxes except for experience in their sector.
- 💡 The speaker believes Michael could quickly pick up the necessary skills despite his lack of direct experience.
- 🙅♀️ The other person in the conversation, Karen, expresses discomfort, saying that this goes against company policies.
- 📝 Karen intends to formally record that the speaker is taking responsibility for this decision.
Q & A
Who is considered the boss in the conversation?
-Diane is considered the boss.
Who is the woman being considered for the position?
-The woman being considered is Johanna.
What concern does the speaker raise about hiring Karen?
-The speaker is concerned that hiring another woman, like Karen, could result in her taking maternity leave, adding to the current strain caused by two employees already on maternity leave.
What does the speaker say about Karen’s qualifications?
-The speaker acknowledges that Karen fits the job specification and that there is a desire to hire more women.
Why is the speaker reluctant to hire another woman?
-The speaker is worried about Karen potentially getting pregnant and taking maternity leave, which could negatively affect productivity and targets.
Who is the other candidate being considered for the role?
-The other candidate being considered is Michael, who ticks all the boxes except for experience in the sector.
Why does the speaker believe Michael is a suitable candidate despite lacking sector experience?
-The speaker believes Michael could quickly pick up the necessary skills even though he lacks direct experience in the sector.
What rationale does the speaker suggest giving Johanna if she is not selected?
-The speaker suggests telling Johanna that concerns about her long commute and the need for someone available at a moment’s notice were the reasons for selecting another candidate who lives closer.
How does the other person in the conversation feel about the speaker’s decision?
-The other person, likely Karen, is unhappy with the decision, stating that it goes against company policies and intends to officially document that the speaker is taking responsibility for the decision.
How does the speaker respond to the objection about violating company policies?
-The speaker accepts the responsibility, saying 'fair enough' in response to the objection about going against policies.
Outlines
🤔 Gender Bias in Hiring Decisions
This paragraph discusses a conversation about a candidate, Johanna, who fits the job description but is not selected for the role. The speaker expresses concerns about hiring another woman due to the possibility of maternity leave, as two of his current employees are already on leave. He argues that hiring women, who might become pregnant, can be disruptive to meeting work targets. Despite knowing this view is against company policies promoting diversity, he prefers a male candidate, Michael, who lacks experience in their sector but could quickly learn. His decision clearly shows gender bias in hiring considerations.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Diversity
💡Maternity leave
💡Gender bias
💡Targets
💡Joanna
💡Michael
💡Commute
💡Hiring policies
💡Responsibility
💡Bias in decision-making
Highlights
Diane is identified as the boss, influencing the decision-making process.
There is a discussion about hiring Johanna, but concerns are raised about her suitability.
Karen advocates for hiring more women, aligning with diversity goals.
Concerns are raised about maternity leave, with two of the best employees currently on leave.
The speaker expresses concern about hiring another woman who might take maternity leave, potentially affecting business targets.
The assumption is made that Johanna might get pregnant, despite there being no indication of her plans.
The speaker emphasizes the importance of practical decision-making over diversity hiring.
Karen highlights that diversity shouldn't impact hiring decisions, but the speaker argues it affects business needs.
The speaker shows preference for a male candidate, Michael, who lacks experience in the sector but ticks most boxes.
Michael was the second choice of Diane, the boss, implying a compromise in the decision-making.
Karen is unhappy with the decision, stating it goes against company policies on diversity.
The speaker suggests an excuse to offer Johanna, such as concerns about her commute.
There is a tension between diversity goals and practical business needs, with the speaker pushing for the latter.
Karen insists on documenting the decision, implying accountability concerns.
The conversation reflects broader issues around gender bias and workplace diversity policies.
Transcripts
well Diane is the boss and she seems to
think we should go through the woman
Johanna isn't it yeah was there someone
you thought was better look the thing is
Karen I know she fits the spec and I
know you want to employ more women but
can we be practical for a moment now
I've got two of my best people off on
maternity leave right now
- now the last thing I need is another
woman who might go and get pregnant she
didn't say she was thinking of having
children but we don't know and even if
we did of course you didn't say I mean
why would she say it shouldn't make any
difference I'm all for diversity you
know I am but try to see things from my
point of view now how am I supposed to
hit my targets when I got people leaving
all the time so who do you want that guy
Michael ticked all the boxes except
experience in our sector Wow you'd soon
pick those things up and he was Diana's
second choice so what should I tell
Joanna
well hello we were worried about the
commute we needed someone who was
available the drop of a hat and we found
another candidate who had the same
skills but live much nearer I'm not
happy about this Andy it's against all
our policies and I'm going to have to
put on record that you take
responsibility for this decision well
fair enough
you
تصفح المزيد من مقاطع الفيديو ذات الصلة
How diversity makes teams more innovative | Rocío Lorenzo | TED
Qualified Employees And Culture - How to Build a Startup
Narrative Therapy Role-Play - Externalizing the Problem - Excessive Worry
Rachel's Handsome Assistant - Learn Spanish with Friends
5 Things you Need to Know BEFORE hiring Employees [watch before you interview]
What question destroys fake seniors in an interview?
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)