ADA HABIB YANG TIDAK MAU DIKRITIK DAN DITEGUR RABITHAH ALAWIYAH ⁉️

Summary

The transcript discusses the challenges faced by the Habib community in Indonesia, particularly the pressure from social media and criticism regarding their teachings on lineage and miracles. It highlights a statement from the Rabitah Alawiyah organization urging Habibs to avoid tarnishing the reputation of Islam with negative behaviors. The speaker reflects on the division within the community, the necessity of dialogue, and the importance of unity. The conversation also addresses ongoing debates about Islamic beliefs and the reluctance to collaborate due to differences in opinion, emphasizing the need for understanding and collaboration across different groups.

Takeaways

• 😀 The Habibs are under intense pressure, with some refusing to engage with books or ideas outside their own circle.
• 😀 There is criticism within the community when individuals seek clarification or confirmation on religious matters, leading to tensions.
• 😀 The Rabitah Alawiyah party released a video urging Habibs to abandon behaviors that tarnish Islam with bad morals and to avoid looking for trouble.
• 😀 Some Habibs use their lineage and stories of miracles to justify their actions, claiming immunity from the law and sins, but this has become a controversial issue.
• 😀 The Rabitah Alawiyah party’s stance has been to distance itself from Habibs who glorify their lineage and stories of supernatural acts, which are seen as divisive.
• 😀 The increasing division within Indonesian society over religious practices, such as between liberals, Wahabis, and other groups, has intensified criticism of the Habibs.
• 😀 Despite the diversity of groups criticizing Habibs, there is a unity in the negative view of superstition and stories of miracles, regardless of political or religious leanings.
• 😀 The widespread attention and social media presence of certain Habibs has caused their actions to be viewed as representative of the entire group, even though not all Habibs share the same beliefs.
• 😀 The current tension surrounding Habibs has led to a growing sentiment that both sides—those supporting lineage and those opposing it—need to find common ground through discussion and clarification.
• 😀 The discussion of differences and disagreements is important for Islamic civilization to evolve, and the reluctance to engage in open dialogue is a major issue.
• 😀 Despite disagreements, the focus should be on collaboration and understanding, as no one person’s beliefs are identical, and unity is essential for building a stronger civilization.

Q & A

What is the primary focus of the Rabitah Alawiyah's video mentioned in the transcript?

The primary focus of the Rabitah Alawiyah's video is to address the current phenomenon among some Habibs who glorify their lineage and claim to be immune from the law, despite committing sins. The video emphasizes the need for these practices to be abandoned and cautions against tarnishing the reputation of Islam with bad morals.

What does the speaker mean when referring to the 'extreme' behavior of some Habibs?

The speaker refers to the 'extreme' behavior of some Habibs who glorify their lineage and display miracles or supernatural stories that stray from traditional Islamic teachings. This behavior often misleads followers and causes division within society.

Why does the speaker suggest that discussions on religious matters are important?

The speaker believes that discussions are crucial to understanding different perspectives and finding a middle ground. They express concern that avoiding discussions leads to one-sided judgment and division, rather than fostering cooperation and mutual understanding.

What concern does the speaker have about the narrative surrounding the Habibs in Indonesia?

The speaker is concerned that the narrative surrounding the Habibs in Indonesia has become distorted, with some of their extreme behaviors being misrepresented as mainstream. They worry this could mislead the general public and tarnish the reputation of Islamic figures who should be viewed with respect.

How does the Rabitah Alawiyah react to the actions of prominent Habibs like Habib Bahar?

Rabitah Alawiyah has taken a stance against Habib Bahar's actions by issuing warnings, both personally and in writing. Despite these warnings, Habib Bahar’s prominence, largely fueled by social media, has overshadowed the Rabitah’s authority, leading to public criticism that impacts the group's image.

What is the significance of 'lineage' in the context of this script?

In this script, 'lineage' refers to the ancestral connection that some Habibs emphasize as a source of their spiritual authority. The speaker critiques this overemphasis on lineage, suggesting that it is being exploited in ways that undermine Islamic teachings and contribute to division within the Muslim community.

Why does the speaker emphasize collaboration despite disagreements?

The speaker advocates for collaboration despite disagreements because they believe that focusing on differences alone prevents the Muslim community from uniting for common goals. By discussing and addressing different opinions, Muslims can work together to achieve shared objectives.

What does the speaker mean by 'extreme meets extreme' in the context of the Habib debate?

The phrase 'extreme meets extreme' refers to the polarization between two opposing sides: those who glorify the Habibs and their lineage through supernatural claims, and those who criticize them for their deviation from traditional Islamic teachings. This clash creates a cycle of extremism that the speaker believes could be resolved through balanced discussions.

What is the concern about religious groups like NU, Salaf, and others in the script?

The speaker highlights the divisions within the Islamic community, where groups like NU and Salaf often disagree on theological matters, such as the nature of Allah. This disagreement, though rooted in centuries-old debates, continues to divide the community, preventing collaboration and unity.

How does the speaker view the role of hierarchy and politics in building a unified society?

The speaker believes that hierarchy and politics are important because they help unite people under a common goal. In this case, a unified Muslim society can achieve greater progress if it focuses on common goals rather than exploiting differences. Politics and hierarchy can provide the structure necessary for achieving this unity.