Real: O Plano Por Trás da História | Ciro Comenta

Summary

This humorous and critical review of the Brazilian film 'Plano Real' delves into its portrayal of the political and economic events surrounding Brazil's 1994 currency reform. The speaker highlights the film's absurdities, from its anachronistic elements like the JK Bridge to its over-the-top characters, including a comedic take on José Serra. Despite its confusion and historical inaccuracies, the film's use of absurd humor and eccentric casting choices, particularly from children's TV stars, makes it a unique and entertaining—but flawed—exploration of Brazil’s political history during the 90s.

Takeaways

• 😀 The movie 'Plano Real' is about the creation of Brazil's economic stabilization plan, the Plano Real.
• 😀 The protagonist of the movie is Gustavo Franco, an economist instrumental in the creation of the plan.
• 😀 The film's storytelling is criticized for being confusing, even for viewers with a background in economics.
• 😀 Humor is a key feature of the film, with moments that stand out, such as those involving José Serra, played by Arthur Col.
• 😀 José Serra's character is praised for being a comedic highlight of the movie, leading the audience to laugh during his scenes.
• 😀 The film’s cast includes actors known for children's shows, like Norival Rizzo, who portrayed characters in 'Ratimbum'.
• 😀 A key criticism of the movie is the portrayal of historical inaccuracies, like showing the JK Bridge, which wasn't built during the film's timeframe.
• 😀 The portrayal of politicians in the movie, including FHC and Itamar Franco, is seen as exaggerated and stylized, reflecting an odd humor.
• 😀 The film's representation of political events, like the 1994 World Cup, is criticized for lack of authenticity, with no Brazilian flags or team jerseys visible.
• 😀 Despite the film’s flaws, the speaker appreciates its existence, acknowledging its artistic value, regardless of its political bias or financial backing.

Q & A

What is the main subject of the movie being discussed in the transcript?

The movie discussed in the transcript focuses on the creation of Brazil's 'Plano Real,' the economic plan that stabilized the country in the 1990s.

Who are the main political figures featured in the film?

The main political figures featured in the film are Fernando Henrique Cardoso (FHC) and Itamar Franco, who played key roles in implementing the 'Plano Real.'

What is the overall tone of the review?

The tone of the review is informal, sarcastic, and humorous, with the reviewer offering both critical reflections and lighthearted commentary on the film's portrayal of historical events and characters.

What is said about the character of José Serra in the film?

The reviewer praises José Serra's portrayal in the film, claiming that the actor, Arthur Col, steals the scene and causes the audience to laugh due to the performance's uniqueness.

How is the film's historical accuracy questioned?

The review criticizes the film for inaccuracies, particularly with the depiction of the Ponte JK, which was not yet built in the 1994 timeframe shown in the movie. The film spans a decade, which the review suggests might explain this discrepancy.

How does the reviewer feel about the character of Gustavo Franco?

The reviewer finds the character of Gustavo Franco to be unremarkable and points out that the film's portrayal of him is not particularly engaging, despite his role in the creation of the 'Plano Real.'

What does the reviewer think of the film's portrayal of the relationship between Gustavo Franco and his wife?

The reviewer criticizes the portrayal of Franco's wife, claiming that the film presents her as a materialistic character who leaves him for another man, only to return after his rise to power. This reflects poorly on her character, according to the review.

What role does the actor Norival Rizo play in the film?

Norival Rizo plays the role of FHC in the film, and the reviewer mentions that Rizo previously acted as the sphinx in the children's show 'Ratimbum,' which adds a humorous layer to his portrayal in the movie.

Why does the reviewer mention the film's handling of the 1994 World Cup?

The reviewer points out the film's strange depiction of the 1994 World Cup, where politicians are shown watching the final match between Brazil and Italy, but none are wearing Brazil jerseys or displaying flags, which detracts from the authenticity of the scene.

What is the reviewer's final opinion on the film?

The reviewer concludes by expressing ambivalence, not knowing if the film was made with political backing from either the PSDB or PT, but ultimately appreciates its existence, regardless of its flaws.