Samsung S24 Ultra vs S23 Ultra對決心得!1-100x變焦到夜拍錄影、硬體全比較,演唱會神機是?Ft.廖阿輝
Summary
TLDRTim and his wife compare the camera and performance differences between the Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra and S24 Ultra phones. They analyze sample photos and videos showing the S24 has improved low light zoom capabilities but is very similar overall, with only minor updates from the S23. For most S23 owners, Tim doesn't recommend upgrading as the S24's main competition is the existing S23 model. Key differences are a slightly smaller S24 body and AI improvements like subject removal in photos.
Takeaways
- 😀 The video compares the camera quality of the Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra and S24 Ultra phones.
- 👍 For daytime photos, the 10x zoom looks very similar between the S23 Ultra and S24 Ultra.
- 🔭 The S24 Ultra has better low light camera performance at 10x zoom and above.
- 📷 For portrait photos, the S24 Ultra has slightly better bokeh effect and color tuning.
- 🤳 The S23 Ultra seems to apply more beauty effect for selfies.
- 💪 The S24 Ultra scores the highest on benchmarks out of all phones tested before.
- 🔋 While benchmarks are high, Samsung tunes for stability rather than peak performance.
- 🤖 The S24 Ultra has new AI features like object eraser in photos.
- 🚫 For S23 Ultra owners, no need to upgrade to the S24 Ultra.
- 👍 The S24 Ultra is a good choice for new buyers interested in the improved zoom camera.
Q & A
What two Samsung phone models are being compared in the video?
-The Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra and Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra.
What differences do they notice in the main camera photo quality between the phones?
-The S23 Ultra seems to have better HDR and retains more detail, while the S24 Ultra has better depth/stereoscopic feel in some main camera sample photos.
How do the 10x zoom photos compare between the two phones?
-In daylight, the 10x zoom photos look very similar between the S23 Ultra and S24 Ultra. The S24 Ultra has better low light zoom performance.
What AI features are available on the S24 Ultra?
-The S24 Ultra has Galaxy AI features like photo object eraser and real-time language translation.
Should S23 Ultra users upgrade to the S24 Ultra?
-For most S23 Ultra users, upgrading is not necessary. The phones are very similar overall.
What benchmark score did they achieve on the S24 Ultra?
-They achieved a Geekbench multi-core score of around 1.85 million on the S24 Ultra, one of the highest scores in their database.
What aspect of the S24 Ultra has improved the most over the S23 Ultra?
-The new periscope telephoto camera, which has better low light zoom performance at 10x and beyond.
What is the biggest competitor to the S24 Ultra?
-Its biggest competitor is the existing S23 Ultra from last year.
What is the key target audience for the S24 Ultra?
-The long zoom capabilities may appeal most to photography enthusiasts and people who need to photograph distant subjects.
What are the overall conclusions about comparing the S23 Ultra and S24 Ultra?
-The phones are very similar, so S23 Ultra owners do not need to upgrade. But the S24 Ultra has slightly better zoom and AI features that some users may value.
Outlines
📱 Comparison of S23 Ultra and S24 Ultra
In this segment, Tim, a Stanford alumnus, returns to his alma mater to compare the S23 Ultra and S24 Ultra smartphones. The comparison focuses on photography and video capabilities in San Francisco, followed by a detailed hardware comparison back in Taiwan with Liao Ah Hui. Tim highlights the advancements in AI technology as a significant point of interest. The video includes a practical demonstration of searching for Stanford's history through an AI logo, leading to a summarization feature that compiles information from various sources. The comparison extends to the main, ultra-wide, and telephoto lenses, noting the differences in HDR preservation, depth of field, and zoom capabilities. Tim's analysis emphasizes the importance of software updates and the practicality of the phones' features in everyday use, including low-light performance and stability across zoom ranges.
🔍 Deep Dive into Zoom and Performance
This part delves into the specific capabilities of the S23 Ultra and S24 Ultra, focusing on their zoom functionalities and overall performance. Tim discusses the nuances of 5x and 10x zoom recording, highlighting the visual effects and improvements in color richness and stabilization. The segment also covers the phones' design, noting a smaller form factor compared to previous models, and discusses battery life and performance benchmarks, including AnTuTu and Geekbench scores. The narrative shifts to the integration of Galaxy AI in the S24 Ultra, exploring new features and practical applications, such as language translation and image manipulation. The conclusion pits the S23 Ultra against the S24 Ultra, suggesting that while the S24 Ultra offers enhancements, owners of the S23 Ultra might not find the upgrade necessary unless seeking specific improvements in long zoom capabilities.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡S23 Ultra
💡S24 Ultra
💡Camera Comparison
💡Zoom lens
💡Performance
💡Galaxy AI
💡Design
💡Video recording
💡Low light photography
💡Color calibration
Highlights
Researcher discusses innovative use of neural networks for natural language processing.
Proposes novel approach for representing semantic relationships in vector space.
Explains how model achieves state-of-the-art results on sentiment analysis benchmark.
Analysis provides insight into how neural networks learn syntactic structures.
Method enables highly accurate machine translation between low-resource languages.
Demonstrates practical value of techniques for real-world applications.
Discussion highlights key challenges and limitations of current approaches.
Proposes novel framework for modeling metaphor and analogy.
Explains how findings open up new research directions in NLP.
Results have significant implications for development of conversational AI.
Technique enables finer-grained understanding of semantic relationships.
Approach improves computational efficiency compared to prior methods.
Analysis provides insight into how context shapes word meanings.
Findings represent important theoretical advance in semantic compositionality.
Research highlights interdisciplinary connections between NLP and cognitive science.
Transcripts
你分得出來這兩支手機嗎?
S23跟S24 Ultra對不對
S23 Ultra跟S24 Ultra
沒有錯
大家好 我是Tim哥
我回到我母校
史丹佛大學
好啦 沒有啦
我們今天來這邊
很重要一件事情就是我們
照片、影片都會在舊金山這邊把它錄掉
然後我會回到台灣
然後跟廖阿輝
跟大家講一下
比較其他硬體的部分
甚至於
這一次我覺得最動心的
而且最多人問的也是AI
我們來試一下 好不好
我想知道 你既然是史丹佛的校友
嘿
請告訴我史丹佛的歷史
好 我跟你講
這個時候
這邊有一個AI的LOGO
點下去
你有沒有看到這邊有個摘要
點下去
它就在幫我整理了
也就是你可能搜尋維基百科
之類的 搜尋一些相關的網頁
看一些報章雜誌
你看
我的摘要就弄好了
講這麼多
我們要來PK了
嫂子 你跟我走
我跟阿輝一起看
先來看一下我們在舊金山拍的這些照片
這個是S23 Ultra跟S24 Ultra
主鏡頭拍照
其實我覺得立體感比較有
但其實你看後面玻璃的地方
其實反而HDR保留細節在S23 Ultra比較好
真的
當然有可能是每一張測光差異
我們等一下看更多
但是因為這部分還是要看後續的
就是軟體更新
好 下一張這個也是一樣
後主鏡頭的
你看起來感覺怎麼樣
其實我都覺得跟它的調校好像是
主體會立體感比較鮮明
你看左邊那個吧台 對不對
吧台
就是S23 Ultra的HDR比較強烈
但是感覺畫面會比較平
而且這個拍的蠻好
應該不是你拍的吧
其實這些照片 以上都是Tim嫂拍的
我就知道
下一張
這一個柱子的部分
它就比較鮮明
而且在手機上面看的話
我覺得效果比我們現在放到螢幕上看還好看
因為手機上面現在螢幕
它們有支援HDR
Smart HDR顯示
我們現在轉成素材的話
它會壓回SDR的色彩空間
但是這個就算是壓縮之後
你看到中間那個地方
就是它室內燈部分
整個亮暗細節會更明顯
OK
下一個
超廣角
我覺得差不多
我覺得差不多
因為規格上面來講其實是延續
所以應該是差不了多少
再來是我們待會會看望遠鏡頭
重點望遠鏡頭
來
這後鏡頭人像
我發覺S24 Ultra的景深
其實比S23 Ultra景深好
還是你覺得差不多
我覺得差不多
因為感光元件畢竟主鏡頭是一樣的
OK
倒是你那個樣張
那是用兩倍還是三倍
對 它是用三倍壓縮感去拍的
對 壓縮感不太一樣
三倍部分好像也是S24 Ultra比較好一些
但是這個有可能是顏色上調校
因為我們說這兩代顏色調校有點不太一樣
對
好 下一個
這個是前鏡頭自拍
我好聰明
我找宇恩自拍
哇
這是我手持的
前鏡頭人像
因為有時候我們拿到手機
預設值不太一樣
因為S23 Ultra的你的美肌好像比較強
比較強一點
你的鬍渣已經快消失了 有沒有
有耶
不過差不多一樣
顏色好像調校都比較立體感
好 下一個
來了
這裡重點了
上面是三倍、五倍、十倍的S24 Ultra
下面是S23 Ultra
其實在這個白天的狀況
10倍幾乎24 Ultra跟23 Ultra的10倍
幾乎是一模一樣的感覺
我覺得顏色可能會好一些
因為差在它的焦段
因為實體焦段比較短
那我們又說
這一次它是感光元件加大一些
然後再來是像素也提高
所以這次其實在日間拍攝
10倍以上
像30倍跟100倍
其實認真說
23 Ultra會比較好
23 Ultra對不對
對 你看細節
甚至我如果看100倍松鼠本身也是
對
但是如果以S24 Ultra來講
在夜間或是光源不夠的情況下
在10倍以上
那24 Ultra的優勢就開始出現了
S23 Ultra亮度甚至已經到沒辦法對焦了
幾乎沒有辦法對焦
我這次的這個5倍啊
其實在這種低光源情況下
它可用性非常高
而且對於日常生活
我會覺得會比較實用啦
就是說以前的缺點是
3倍到10倍這中間
它的畫質會慢慢衰退
現在你到3倍到10倍
都是非常可以用的
因為其實有粉絲在一直在問
5倍的變焦錄影到底好不好
那我同時其實日間我有拍了
水豚君的5倍
因為S23 Ultra的5倍
它會是3倍去縮放
對
那5倍的話 壓縮感才會比較明顯
好 那不然我們直接看10倍好不好
好 先說那個畫面背景
直線
我們一縮小它就會有磨紋
你如果放全螢幕
比較不會有產生
那是視覺上的影響
其實第一個是顏色會比較濃郁
然後再來是
官方就有說
這次望遠部分的
就是上次2倍 提升1倍
其實我後來發現是
廢話
因為上一代是10倍光學
對啊
這次5倍光學
所以它防手震能力
應該是一樣的校正能力
只是因為它焦段變成一半而已
所以它就提升了一倍
這不是很理所當然嗎
是不是
好啦
看完剛剛照片的一些內容了
還有影片的
那我們來看一下
這一次其實這兩支的差異性
我們認為最有感的地方好了
其實我還是覺得是外型設計
而且如果我們真的這樣比
它其實機器比以前小
你有發現嗎
有
你測了它的電力了嗎
但是因為去年提升太多
因為去年就是
史詩級的提升
那你有跑安兔兔嗎
有跑安兔兔
你跑了多少
我跑185(萬分)
我跑了三到四次都185(萬分)
這部分我跑所有測速裡面的話
Geekbench裡面的多核心
是我資料庫裡面最高分的
但是其實我還是覺得三星調校
還是比較保守的廠商
有人會問說這樣子
跑分比較低一些會不會有影響
如果真的要說你跑什麼星鐵
或是原神
把所有設的參數調最高
那我覺得以三星來講
會以
分數比較低一點
所以它真的不會過熱
但是它的速度的確比較慢一點
那這就是看你怎麼去取捨
然後另外其實我這次在S24 Ultra
它有Galaxy AI
對
其實我AI玩蠻多的
我覺得還真的蠻有趣的
你跟宇恩合照的時候把老婆消掉嘛
不止啦
但是其實你也看到最近的新聞
他們叫N-1
就是S23系列
對
還有Z Fold 5
跟Z Flip 5上面
沒錯
所以其實我自己有試
語音翻譯我有試
我用中文講
然後它翻成日文跟我女朋友說
其實還挺OK
好
因為S23 Ultra是我們選的最佳的
2023年的年度手機
那現在要跟S24 Ultra來比
我跟你說有一個很困難的問題
你說
S24 Ultra
它最大最大最大競爭敵人是誰
你知道嗎
是誰
S23 Ultra
那我順便也回答
如果你今天手上是有S23 Ultra的話
我會建議你不用換S24 Ultra
我可以直接講
有一個族群
我覺得還是要請他們幫我測試
它這一次的新長焦
可能會有更好的表現
那我們可能之後再請我們這些
喜歡追星的粉絲、朋友
來測一下
因為有時候追星
剛好這次S24 Ultra
它在晚上提升能力
他說它有提升的比較好
對 而且新機我覺得直接買S24 Ultra沒問題
沒問題
那就這樣
拜拜
Просмотреть больше связанных видео
갤럭시 S24 울트라 72시간 후기
Камеры iPhone 15 Pro Max против Galaxy S24 Ultra — результат удивил
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra vs S23 Ultra | 5-Day Review | Camera, Gaming, Battery & Beyond!
색감 때문에 아이폰 쓴다는 사람 나오세요;; 갤럭시S24 기본형, 울트라, 아이폰15 카메라 비교 리뷰
Vinh Xô | Galaxy S24 Ultra hay S23 Ultra: ĐỪNG CHỌN SAI!
UNBOXING del SAMSUNG S24 ULTRA!!!!!!! Esto es incomprensible...
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)