TMC’s Mahua Moitra Roasts Modi Govt In Lok Sabha; 'This Is Blood Money…’ | Watch

Summary

In this passionate address, a representative from the All India Trinamool Congress critiques the Finance Bill, expressing deep concern over the government's budgetary allocations. The speaker argues that the budget fails to address the needs of the middle class and the poor, highlighting regressive taxation and reduced social sector funding. They stress the disproportionate tax burden on the middle class and the lack of adequate support for agriculture, employment, and social security. The speech culminates in a call for a more equitable and responsive fiscal policy, warning of the government's neglect of pressing social and economic issues as it prepares for the upcoming elections.

Takeaways

• 😡 The speaker expresses disappointment with the absence of key government figures during the discussion of the finance bill.
• 💰 The budget is criticized for failing to address the needs of the poor and middle class, emphasizing that it favors business as usual rather than necessary reforms.
• 📉 Direct taxes are highlighted as progressive while indirect taxes disproportionately burden the lower-income population, with 65% of tax revenue coming from indirect taxes in India.
• 🔄 The middle class is paying a greater share of direct income taxes under the current government compared to wealthy corporations.
• 🚫 Changes in taxation, such as the removal of indexation, are viewed as harmful to the savings of middle-class individuals, particularly pensioners and salaried professionals.
• 📉 Social sector allocations have decreased significantly when adjusted for inflation, impacting essential programs that support the poor and vulnerable populations.
• 🛡️ Defense spending is described as inadequate, with allocations falling to the lowest percentage of GDP since 1960, raising concerns about national security.
• 🌾 Agricultural support is deemed insufficient, with a stark contrast between funding for agriculture and high-cost projects like bullet trains.
• 👥 The government is accused of failing to create jobs, with more informal employment rather than formal opportunities arising.
• ⚖️ The speaker calls for a reevaluation of priorities in budgeting, urging for increased transparency and support for crucial social programs.

Q & A

What is the speaker's main concern regarding the government during the discussion of the Finance Bill?

The speaker expresses deep disappointment over the absence of key government officials, like the Prime Minister and Finance Minister, during important discussions on the Finance Bill, indicating a lack of engagement with pressing issues.

How does the speaker criticize the current budget's approach to taxation?

The speaker highlights that the current budget heavily relies on indirect taxes, which are regressive and burden everyone equally, rather than ensuring a fair distribution of tax responsibilities through direct taxes.

What specific demographic does the speaker mention as being particularly affected by the budget's tax policies?

The speaker points out that the middle class and the poor are disproportionately impacted by the budget's tax policies, noting that the middle class now shoulders a greater tax burden than wealthy corporations.

What changes to capital gains taxation does the speaker find problematic?

The speaker criticizes the removal of indexation benefits for capital gains, which penalizes low-profit investors, particularly impacting pensioners and risk-averse individuals who rely on safe investments.

According to the speaker, how have social sector allocations changed in real terms over the past decade?

The speaker states that while nominal allocations to social sectors have increased, real allocations adjusted for inflation have decreased by over 25% in the last decade, indicating a reduction in support for essential programs.

What issue does the speaker raise about the government's defense spending?

The speaker argues that the defense budget has been reduced, representing the lowest percentage of GDP for defense since 1960, which raises concerns about India's military preparedness amid threats from neighboring countries.

How does the speaker perceive the government's approach to agricultural development?

The speaker criticizes the low allocation for agriculture compared to other projects, like a bullet train, arguing that this reflects a lack of genuine commitment to supporting the agricultural sector, which employs a significant portion of the population.

What are the speaker's views on job creation and employment opportunities in the current budget?

The speaker is skeptical about the government's job creation track record, highlighting that most employment is informal and criticizing proposals in the budget as inadequate for addressing the needs of the workforce.

What does the speaker say about the government's treatment of social security pensions?

The speaker points out that the central government's contribution to social security pensions has remained unchanged since 2014, emphasizing the inadequacy of support for the poorest segments of society.

What conclusion does the speaker draw about the overall effectiveness of the budget?

The speaker concludes that the budget is a 'kury Baja budget' that fails to address the mandates of the people, reflecting a desperate attempt by the government to ignore the realities faced by citizens, and anticipates instability and ineffectiveness in economic policies.